REGULAR BERKELEY CITY
COUNCIL MEETING
TUESDAY,
JANUARY 26,
1999
SUMMARY
Preliminary Matters
Roll Call: 7:03 p.m. All present.
Ceremonial Matters:
Commended Sam Dyke for his work with the Adeline-Alcatraz Merchants Association for the
proposed improvements in the Adeline Corridor.
Action: Moved, seconded carried (Armstrong/Olds) to commend Tamlyn Bright of
Mayor Deans office and Calvin Fong of Councilmember Maios office for their
exemplary services during the move of Council offices to 1900 Addison Street.
Comments From The City Manager:
Steve Barton has been appointed Interim Housing Director effective January 26, 1999.
Final workshop on the Marina Master Plan will be held on February 6, 1999 at 10:00 a.m.
at the Berkeley Yacht Club.
The City of Berkeley has received the Project Impact Model Community Award from the
Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) and was designated as "Community of the
Year" nationally.
Comments From The Public: Eight speakers.
Consent Calendar
Action: Moved, seconded, carried (Shirek/Maio) to approve Consent Calendar items
in one vote except as indicated.
1. From: City Manager
Recommendation: Adopt a Resolution reviewing and confirming the continued existence of
a local emergency with regard to HIV transmission from use of HIV-infected needles among
injection drug users, and authorizing the Director of Public Health to take steps to
enable the operation of needle exchange emergency distribution.
Contact: Manuela Albuquerque, City Attorney, 644-6380
Action: Adopted Resolution No. 59,858-N.S.
2. Ordinances for Second Reading:
a. Amending Ordinance No. 6447-N.S., Chapter 20.66 of the Berkeley Municipal Code,
to prohibit tobacco product advertising within 1400 feet of schools.
b. Adding Chapter 20.67 to Title 20, Signs, of the Berkeley Municipal Code to prohibit
advertising of alcohol products in publicly visible locations within 1400 feet of schools.
(Noes: Armstrong, Olds, Woolley)
c. Amending Sign Ordinance No. 4291-N.S. (Berkeley Municipal Code Title 20) to reduce
the minimum height over the sidewalk of projecting signs and making various other
technical and typographical corrections.
d. Repealing and readopting Chapter 19.40 and Chapter 19.44 of the Berkeley Municipal
Code, Section 1 of Ordinance No. 6312-N.S.
e. Amending Section 13.84.060, Subdivisions (B) and (C) of the Berkeley Municipal Code
(Relocation Services and Payments for Residential Tenant Households Ordinance No.
5725-N.S.
Contact: Sherry M. Kelly, City Clerk, 644-6480
Action: Adopted second reading of a) Ordinance No. 6472-N.S., b) Ordinance No.
6473-N.S. (Noes Armstrong, Olds, Woolley), c) Ordinance No. 6474-N.S., d) Ordinance
No. 6475-N.S. and e) Ordinance No. 6476-N.S.
3. Contract: Environmental Impact Report (EIR) for Playing Field at East Campus
From: City Manager
Recommendation: Adopt a Resolution authorizing the City Manager to execute a contract
and any amendments with LSA Associates, Inc. in an amount not to exceed $95,000 to prepare
an Environmental Impact Report for a playing field at East Campus, and to evaluate two
design concepts which includes Derby Street closed and the option of leaving Derby Street
open as the most viable alternative. Neither option to include any field lighting or
amplified sound system.
Contact: Lisa Caronna, Parks and Waterfront, 644-6943
Action: Adopted Resolution No. 59,859-N.S.
4. Fiscal Year 1997-98 Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) Carryover Funds
From: City Manager (to be delivered)
Recommendation:
Recommendation: Adopt a Resolution reappropriating $1,676,071 of committed
carryover funds from Fiscal Year 1997-98 CDBG Grant Program to Fiscal Year 1998-99, and
refer $91,458 in uncommitted Fiscal Year 1997-98 CDBG funds to the Fiscal Year 1999-2000
CDBG budget allocation process.
Contact: Weldon Rucker, Deputy City Manager, 644-6580
Action: Withdrawn by the City Manager.
5. Honoring Censure and Move On Group
From: Councilmember Woolley
Recommendation: Adopt a proclamation honoring the group Censure and Move On, which is
using the internet as a means to enable people to voice their opposition to the
impeachment and possible removal from office of President William Jefferson Clinton. The
proclamation would be formally read during the Ceremonial Matters section of the February
9, 1999 Council meeting. The proclamation is to honor Censure and Move Ons founders,
as well as everyone who has gotten involved.
Contact: Diane Woolley, Councilmember District 5, 644-6294
Action: Approved Proclamation to be presented at the February 9, 1999 meeting.
6. Moratorium on New Restaurants
From: Councilmember Spring
Recommendation: Refer the request for a moratorium on new restaurants, especially fast
food restaurants in the downtown area, to the Planning Commission and request that the
Commission form a staffed subcommittee to work with representatives of downtown
businesses, including restaurants and coffee shop owners, to develop a quota plan similar
to other commercial areas such as Telegraph and Solano Avenues.
Contact: Dona Spring, Councilmember District 4, 644-6266
Action: Removed from the Consent Calendar by Councilmember Maio. Held over to
February 9, 1999.
7. Traffic Mitigation for Public Safety Building
From: Councilmembers Spring and Worthington
Recommendation: Direct the City Manager to expeditiously install a pedestrian,
bicycle, car activated traffic signal at Martin Luther King Jr. Way and Center Streets as
required by the public safety building mitigations approved in the final EIR; and report
back to the Council on a timetable for its installation.
Contact: Dona Spring, Councilmember District 4, 644-6266; Kriss Worthington, Councilmember
District 7, 644-6398
Action: Withdrawn by Councilmember Spring.
8. Transportation Equity Act for the 21st Century
From: Vice Mayor Shirek
Recommendation: 1) request staff to initiate an application for Transportation Equity
Act for the 21st Century (Transportation for Livable Communities Capital
Program TEA-21), funding for streetscape and sidewalk/pedestrian improvements in the
Adeline Corridor to implement the South Berkeley Area Plan, as specified in a letter from
Sam Dyke, Chair of the Adeline-Alcatraz Merchants Association; 2) accept Sam Dykes
offer for the City to partner with the Adeline-Alcatraz Merchants Association in the
application and the community design process for the improvements; 3) adopt a Resolution
to provide City funds of $20,000 for the community design process to
match $10,000 provided by the Adeline-Alcatraz Merchants Association; 4) in addition,
request staff to pursue explore a "Transportation for Livable
Communities" planning grant to plan other improvements and enhance the
relationship between the Ashby BART Station, the new Ed Roberts Campus, and the
surrounding residential and business communities; 5) direct the City Manager to report
back to Council with a schedule for the grant applications and community design process; and
6) request the City Manager to thank Mr. Dyke for his initiative and community spirit in
initiating a long over-due implementation of a part of the South Berkeley Area Plan, and
(7) to affirm Council commitment of matching funds of up to 11.5% of the final grant
amount.
Contact: Maudelle Shirek, Councilmember District 3, 644-6243
Action: Removed from the Consent Calendar by Councilmember Shirek. Moved,
seconded, carried (Shirek/Maio) to approve recommendation as amended above and to adopt
Resolution No. 59,860-N.S.
Action Calendar
Appeals:
9. Housing Advisory Commission Appeal 3208 Ellis Street
a. Appeal filed by Isaac Trunnell, of the Housing Advisory Commissions
decision to uphold the Building Officials determination to allow the owners of 3208
Ellis Street until March 9, 1999 to complete repairs required to bring the structure up to
Berkeley Housing Code standards.
Contact: Sherry Kelly, City Clerk, 644-6480
b. City Managers Report
Recommendation: Adopt a Resolution affirming the decision of the Housing Advisory
Commission (HAC) to uphold the Building Officials determination to allow the owners
of 3208 Ellis Street until March 9, 1999 to complete repairs required to bring the
structure up to Berkeley Housing Code standard, and dismissing the appeal of the tenant.
Contact: Liz Epstein, Planning & Development, 705-8110
Action: Moved to Consent Calendar by Councilmember Worthington to approve the
City Manager recommendation. Adopted Resolution No. 59,861-N.S. Abstain - Spring.
10. Public Hearing Regarding Zoning Appeal of Use Permits 3033 and 3681 699
Virginia Street (Berkeley Asphalt)
a. Appeal filed by Nora Chorover on behalf of Ocean View Neighborhood Association and
Communities for a Better Environment, of the Zoning Adjustments Board decision to take
no action to initiate revocation proceedings for Use Permits based on certain findings for
the property located at 699 Virginia Street.
Contact: Sherry M. Kelly, City Clerk, 644-6480
b. City Manager Report
Recommendation: 1) Conduct a public hearing and upon conclusion adopt a Resolution
affirming the decision of the Zoning Adjustments Board with findings that Berkeley Asphalt
and Ready Mix is in compliance with the conditions of Use Permits 3033 and 3681, and based
on the evaluation provided by expert consultants and affected agencies, as well as the
testimony, the current operation of the Berkeley Asphalt and Ready Mix Companies does not
constitute a nuisance. If Council after considering the record, is unable to determine
whether there is a nuisance or violation of conditions, continue the hearing without
action to coincide with the six month review by staff required pursuant to Use Permit 3033
six months after initiation of operation of the approved replacement equipment for the
asphalt plant.
Contact: Liz Epstein, Planning and Development, 705-8105
c. Communication from December 8, 1998:
1) Rena Rickles, Attorney on behalf of Berkeley Asphalt, applicant
d. Communication:
1) Nora Chorover, Attorney for Ocean View Neighborhood Association
Contact: Sherry M. Kelly, City Clerk, 644-6480
Action: The Mayor opened the public hearing. Thirty-three speakers heard. Moved,
seconded, carried (Maio/Worthington; Absent Armstrong, Olds) to discuss the matter
in closed session on February 9, 1999; to continue the public hearing to February 16, 1999
for additional testimony; and to list the item on the agenda of February 9, 1999 for
possible announcement of a change in hearing date.
11. Continued Public Hearing Regarding Adoption of a New Zoning Ordinance
From: City Manager
Recommendation: Conduct a public hearing and upon conclusion, continue the matter to
February 9th to: 1) adopt a resolution approving a Negative Declaration under
the provisions of the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA); 2) adopt first reading
of an Ordinance repealing Ordinance Nos. 413-N.S. and 3018-N.S. and adopting a new Zoning
Ordinance and Official Zoning Map; and 3) direct the Planning Commission in consultation
with the Zoning Adjustments Board (ZAB) and the Landmarks Preservation Commission (LPC),
to review the revised Ordinance six months after its effective date to evaluate the
effectiveness of the Ordinance changes, consider items referred by the Council and others
in the "Six Month List", and recommend proposals on additional changes which are
needed.
Contact: Liz Epstein, Planning and Development, 705-8105
a. Planning Commission Report
Recommendation: 1) Initiate an amendment to the C-1(T) District regulations as
follows: a) prohibit new off-sale alcohol establishments, b) prohibit the establishment of
any new use which involved the sale and distribution of drug paraphernalia, as defined in
the Health and Safety Code, and c) require a Use Permit from the Zoning Adjustments Board
for any new use involving the sale and distribution of tobacco products and associated
merchandise; 2) Consider Citywide zoning changes to prevent alcohol-related and drug
paraphernalia uses proposed to be prohibited in the C-1(T) District from locating in other
parts of the City; and 3) Consider a comprehensive package designed to address the root
causes of alcoholism and drug abuse.
Contact: Karen Haney-Owens, Secretary, 705-8105
b. Communications from 1998:
1. Martha Nicoloff
2. Landmarks Preservation Commission
3. Berkeley Architectural Heritage Association
4. Doris Willingham, LPC ZO Review Subcommittee
5. Daniella Thompson and James Sharp
6. Catherine Roha, A.I.A.,
7. Landmarks Preservation Commission
8. Joe Marsh, LPC Chair
9. Carrie Sprague and Nancy Holland
c. Communication:
1. Martha Nicoloff
Contact: Sherry M. Kelly, City Clerk, 644-6480
Action: Eight speakers heard. Moved, seconded, failed (Maio/Spring) to close the
public hearing and refer to the Planning Commission: Ordinance consistency with Measure L;
zoning of parks including Aquatic Park zoning, Live-Work regulations, the 500
sq.ft.
within one year rule, group living or accommodation of persons vs. rooms, and noticing
period requirement.
Action: Moved, seconded, carried a substitute motion (Armstrong/Worthington;
Absent Olds) to continue the public hearing to February 9, 1999, taking no new
comments or issues, and that staff address only the questions or issues that were
presented at this meeting.
Old Business:
12. Reimbursement for Overpayment of Sewer Bills (removed from Consent by
Councilmember Spring from December 8, 1998 meeting and held over from January 12, 1999
meeting)
From: Councilmembers Armstrong, Olds, Woolley and Mayor Dean
Recommendation: Ask the City to reimburse Berkeley residents who have paid unfairly
high sewer bills in the months between July 1998 when the Council passed the sewer tax
cap, and January 1999 when East Bay Municipal Utility District (EBMUD) will finally
re-order their billing to reflect that cap.
Contact: Polly Armstrong, Councilmember District 8, 644-6401; Shirley Dean, Mayor,
644-6484; Betty Olds, Councilmember District 6, 644-6399; Diane Woolley, Councilmember
District 5, 644-6294
a. City Manager Report (to be delivered)
Contact: Frances David, Finance, 644-6476
Action: Moved, seconded, carried (Armstrong/Worthington; Absent Olds) to
provide refunds for sewer service overcharges to users who apply to the City in writing
with written proof of overcharge; that staff notify individually those people who have
notified the City previously; that all users will be notified in a future sewer billing
that refunds exceeding $50.00 will be made in the amount above the $50.00 threshold and
that a reminder of low income provisions be included.
13. City of Emeryville Proposal to Reconfigure Ashby Interchange of I-80 (held
over from the January 12, 1999 meeting)
From: Transportation Commission
Recommendation: That Council take the following action: (1) Direct that the City of
Berkeley continue, in conjunction with Emeryville and CalTrans, to explore reconfiguring
the Ashby interchange, and indicate that the City of Berkeley does not at this time
support or oppose the proposal, but reserves the right to support or oppose the proposal
at a future date; (2) request that the City of Emeryville or CalTrans provide funds for an
independent traffic study managed by Berkeley to review the many traffic and related
issues raised by the Ashby interchange proposal. This study would review the traffic and
land use implications of various possible projects at the Ashby interchange, including the
project as proposed by Emeryville, relocation of the Potter Street on-ramp only, and
possibly another alternative; and (3) request that CalTrans delay approval of the Project
Study Report (PSR) for the reconfiguration of the Ashby/I-80 interchange until such time
as this independent traffic study can be completed to the satisfaction of the City of
Berkeley.
Contact: Nathan Landau, Transportation Commission Secretary, 705-8136
a. City Manager Report
Recommendation: Concurs with the content and recommendations of the Commission.
Contact: Liz Epstein, Planning and Development, 705-8105
Action: Withdrawn by the City Manager.
New Business:
14. AT&T-TCI Franchise Transfer
From: City Manager
Recommendation: Adopt a Resolution denying without prejudice the application of
Tele-Communications, Inc. (TCI) to transfer control of the cable television franchise to
AT&T Corporation (AT&T).
Contact: Phil Kamlarz, Deputy City Manager, 644-6580
Action: Withdrawn by the City Manager.
Information Reports
15. Aquatic Park Sound Barrier Project
From: City Manager
Contact: Lisa Caronna, Parks and Waterfront, 644-6943
Action: Received and filed.
16. Fee Waiver for Bonita House
From: City Manager
Contact: Liz Epstein, Planning and Development, 705-8105
Action: Received and filed.
17. Welfare Reform: Preliminary Impact Analysis
From: City Manager
Contact: Arrietta Chakos, City Managers Office, 644-6580
Action: Received and filed.
18. Guidelines for Late-Night Youth Activities
From: Berkeley Youth Commission
Contact: Philip Harper-Cotton, Secretary, 644-6226
Action: Moved to the Consent Calendar by Councilmember Worthington. Endorsed
guidelines.
Communications
Council rules limit action on Communications to referral to the City Manager and/or
Boards and Commissions for investigation and/or recommendations.
1. John Vance, Coordinator, A First Amendment Center, regarding Utne Readers Y2K
Citizens Action Guide. Maio and referred to the City Managers task force on
Y2K preparedness.
2. Preston J. Taylor, ASUC President, regarding expansion of the Cal
Student Store. Worthington
3. Patrick Kennedy, transmitting newspaper article re various
developments.
4. Bill Hughson, President, A.G. Ferrari Foods, regarding
enforcement of sidewalk signage regulations. Maio, Woolley, Dean
5. Tim Cannon, Chair, North Berkeley Merchants Assn., requesting
payment of the $20,000 allocated to the Association in the Citys budget. Olds,
Woolley, Dean, Spring
6. L.A. Wood, regarding hazardous waste incineration. Spring,
Dean
7. William Dale Crist, President, Board of Administration, California Public
Employees Retirement System, regarding retirement
credit for Peace Corps and Vista service. Dean, Woolley.
8. L.A. Wood, regarding Work Group minutes and facilitation. Breland
Adjournment
The meeting adjourned at 11:51 p.m. in memory of Charles Brown, Marjorie Farquhar,
Margaret Owings, Trevor Thomas and Myrtle Wright.